The Critical Edition of the Complete Works


by Reinhold Kubik

One of the principal activities of the International Gustav Mahler Society. Since Gustav Mahler's works were protected by copyright law until the 70th anniversary of his death (1981), it was decided to have each volume published by the holder of the rights. This practice was continued even after Mahler's works entered the "public domain" in 1981.

The first volume, the 7th Symphony, was published in 1960, the 100th anniversary of Mahler's birth. The editor (until his death in 1973) was Erwin Ratz, who by 1967 had already brought out 7 volumes. His guiding priciple was to document the last known version of each work, based on the conviction that all of Mahler's many retouches and revisions could only have represented improvements. The critical notes and source documentation were kept to a minimum, mainly because no publisher at the time was prepared to invest money in the future of Mahler's works. Very few people at that time expected their popularity to increase significantly.

During this period Ferdinand Redlich edited six volumes of Mahler for the Edition Eulenburg, and took the opposing viewpoint: he accepted only the original version of a work as being valid.

Erwin Ratz edited a total of ten volumes. From 1974 to 1993 the editor-in-chief was Karl Heinz Füssl. Whereas Ratz had done everything alone, Füssl assembled a team of qualified Mahler experts: Zoltan Roman edited volumes of songs, Peter Revers the early Lieder, Stephen Hefling the version of Das Lied von der Erde with piano accompaniment, Rudolf Stephan Das klagende Lied and Totenfeier. Füssl himself edited the 8th Symphony and devoted his energy to the difficult work of correcting, revising and completing earlier volumes, an undertaking which is still continuing today. Under Füssl more emphasis was placed upon the critical notes documenting the research and sources.

After Füssl's death Reinhold Kubik took charge of the Complete Works. The next volumes to be completed were the Wunderhorn-Lieder in piano and orchestra versions (Renate Hilmar-Voit), the early piano quartet movement (Manfred Wagner-Artzt), the original version of Das klagende Lied in three movements (Reinhold Kubik) and the 5th Symphony (Reinhold Kubik). New editions of the Second (Renate Stark-Voit/Gilbert Kaplan) and the Seventh (Reinhold Kubik) will be finished in due course. All these new volumes with the title "Neue kritische Gesamtausgabe" have an extensive section of notes with preface, critical comments and illustrations. Kubik feels that both the original versions as well as later revisions and several of the "Retuschen" possess artistic validity. Future work on the project will be based upon this premise.

future plans